PORT-OF-SPAIN, TRINIDAD

This film is held by the BFI (ID: 20284).

Synopsis

Travelogue showing the people and buildings of Port-of-Spain, Trinidad.

The initial title explains that 'this capital city of the most southern West Indian island is an extremely interesting place, combining exotic East Indian, true negro and typical English types to create an atmosphere unlike any other in the Caribbean'. A map indicates the distance from America to Trinidad and offers some geographical statistics about the area, before another title notes the city's links with both English and American towns. The opening footage is of the harbour. A panning shot from left to right reveals fishing boats and locals gathered along the quayside. Crowds of locals stand around the customs office, including white men in bowler hats and local policemen. Others wander up and down the jetty - where the camera is positioned - and stare at the camera. The camera pans further right to show locals at work, sorting baskets and sacks, next to a boat filled with watermelons. The next title introduces 'Broadway and Frederick Street, where Trinidad comes to trade'. A tram travels towards the camera, while further shots reveal shop fronts, horse drawn carts and a crowd of locals waiting for a tram as a woman walks by carrying fruit on her head. The next title states that 'Trinidad's only railway is thoroughly English' as a steam train leaves the station, with passengers leaning out of the window.

The film then focuses on the local people - 'Trinidad has more than 100,000 East Indians. This much-decorated individual is one of their Hindu priests' - as a Hindu priest holds an umbrella and poses for the camera. A succession of shots show prominent local sites - 'The Red House, or Government Buildings', Queen's Park, where crowds are watching a football match, and Marine Square, where three Indian men and two women sit on the grass and pass around a pipe. Shops in the background include 'The Trinidad Stores, Salvatori, Scott & Co.'. Three other Indians are seated by the pavement, as the film shows local tradesmen preparing food and cutting hair. Further landmarks follow - the Roman Catholic Cathedral, Queen's Royal College, Government House, where two men guard the gated entrance, and Trinidad Hospital. This is followed by 'a village shoemaker whose shop is the sidewalk' making wooden shoes. The next title explains that 'Trinidad keeps its streets clean. Women do the work' before shots of women sweeping a deserted village street. The film briefly shows some of the local shanty towns - 'where many of Trinidad's poor live' - before returning to the more affluent residential areas. The film concludes with a shot of these clear empty streets with trees and a hedge in front of a large house.

 

Context

A Bioscope review for the first films within Granger’s ‘Marvels of the Universe’ series explained that the travel films were produced by the Educational Film Corporation of New York and then acquired by Granger’s (Bioscope, 19 June 1919, 89). It is highly probable that Port-of-Spain, Trinidad was made by Robert C. Bruce. A report in Charleston Daily Mail in April 1920 confirmed that Bruce, ‘who has made motion picture studies of nature in a greater portion of this country for Educational Films’, had just completed a tour of Cuba and Jamaica ‘and promises a number of novelties’ (Charleston Daily Mail, 4 April 1920, 12). Bruce travelled extensively, embarking on a five-month trip to Europe in the second half of the year. A subsequent report outlined Bruce’s working methods and the control he exercised over his films – he is ‘said to be the only scenic artist in the world who actually cuts and titles his own pictures’, while he ‘writes his scenarios before taking a foot of pictures so that every scene he photographs is made with a purpose’ (Charleston Daily Mail, 3 December 1920, 13). 

The Times discussed the launch of Granger’s ‘Marvels of the Universe’ series in June 1919, under the sub-heading ‘educational pictures’. ‘There has been much discussion of late as to the value of the cinematograph in education’, the paper wrote, before asserting that the ‘educational value’ of this new series ‘is undoubted’. The president of the Educational Film Corporation outlined the potential impact of the series, while the report further noted that ‘an effort is to be made to interest the educational authorities in these pictures’ (The Times, 16 June 1919, 16). The films continued to be promoted in an educational context over the next two years. For example, before a screening of new ‘Marvels’ in March 1921 – shown to ‘a distinguished audience’ including royalty, social leaders and ‘educationists’ – Helen Normanton gave ‘an unusually interesting and thoughtful speech concerning the future of educational cinematography’ (Bioscope, 10 March 1921, 6).

Bioscope also bestowed lavish praise on the series, noting the significance of the travel picture in film history – ‘it was by the travel film that the picture theatre made its first successful appeal to the public’ – and its importance in legitimizing the industry (‘no other type of picture has done more to stabilize and promote the good reputation of the Industry’). This ‘educational’ series was thus presented within the broader context of the widespread debates over cinema and morality, as the review suggested it responded to the ‘higher needs of the cinema’. Bioscope did however complain about some of the titling – which it argued was evidently catering for an American audience – and suggested substituting ‘more racily written sub-titles for the rather dull statements of unnecessary facts which at present occupy the screen’ (Bioscope, 19 June 1919, 79, 80). By 1920 Granger’s was advertising the series as ‘the most consistent success of 1919’ and adopting the tagline ‘we place the world before you’ (Bioscope, 6 January 1920, 37).

In November 1919 the waterfront workers in Trinidad struck for higher wages and improved working conditions. The cost of living had increased by 148% since 1914, while wages had gone up by only 36% for men and 28% for women. The strike escalated into violent protests in Port-of-Spain at the beginning of December (Kiely, 1996, 67). Howard Johnson viewed this as an indication of ‘increased working class militancy’ which, he argued, ‘overlapped with a sense of black racial pride and identity’ (Johnson, 1999, 600). While Peter Fryer’s claim that these strikes ‘brought British colonialism to its knees’ may be an overstatement, this does undoubtedly mark a point of heightened racial and class tensions (Fryer, 1984, 312). Colonial reports largely blamed these problems on returning soldiers, but the situation was exacerbated by the government’s response, as it arrested and deported leaders involved in the strikes and introduced reforms, which were deemed wholly inadequate by the protesters. The protests and strikes continued into 1920. For example, labourers seeking higher pay struck at the government railways in July 1920.

When the Prince of Wales visited Port-of-Spain in September 1920 as part of his tour of the Empire, he attended a dinner at Government House at which he rejected the suggestion that ‘the British Empire might be willing to part with one or more British West Indian islands to a foreign power’. ’I can assure you’, he continued, ‘that the King and all of us in the Old Country have very much at heart the welfare of Trinidad and all the British West Indies, as of all other British possessions’ (The Times, 20 September 1920, 9). 

 

Analysis

It is evident from the outset that Port-of-Spain is an American production with titles – as the Bioscope criticism noted – primarily tailored towards an American audience. An opening title marks the distance on the map between New York and Trinidad – 2200 miles – before next noting that ‘though typically English in many respects, Port-of-Spain exhibits an alert activity characteristic of many American towns’. The titles thus present the footage within an American context, while the film’s much-touted pedagogical function is also apparent in its display of a map indicating the area in square miles of the island and its population.

For modern audiences, the film is perhaps most interesting as a source of footage of Port-of-Spain during a period of labour unrest and of heightened racial and anti-colonial tension. In particular, the film offers lengthy shots of the quayside, of local police, of workers and of the streets, as the camera slowly pans over the scenes allowing the viewer to explore the frame. The multi-racial nature of the island is highlighted – the opening title states that it combines ‘exotic East Indian, true negro and typical English types to create an atmosphere unlike any other in the Caribbean’ – yet the representation of these races varies enormously. The camera depicts locals within their daily routine and presents ethnographic shots of the East Indians, presenting a Hindu priest posing in close-up and later showing a group of five Indians smoking a pipe and performing for the camera. Yet, aside from a few people in bowler hats by the quayside, there are very few shots of the white inhabitants and there is little evidence of any interaction. 

The film does note the British influence within the island – ‘Trinidad’s only railway is thoroughly English’ – and highlights the continued British presence, yet this is represented in an entirely different manner from that of the local non-Europeans. While the non-Europeans are depicted in lengthy sequences, with close-ups of often bustling local activities, the European experience is represented through a series of brief long shots that reveal distant government buildings rather than people, denoting a more formal, governmental presence. There is little movement or activity within the frame now, and this division is further emphasised through the editing. For example, a shot of Government’s House – protected and cut off, both from the public and the viewer, by a large gate and two policemen – is followed by a scene of two local tradesmen making shoes in front of the camera. The contrast, in terms of wealth and standard of living, is noted through a title, which explains that ‘a dozen pairs may be bought for that many dollars’. This contrast is reiterated in the final two sequences, as footage of a local shanty town – ‘where many of Trinidad’s poor live’ – is followed by the ‘verdant beauty’ of the residential streets favoured by Europeans. Thus, while the film does not directly address or highlight the strikes and unrest within the island, it does emphasise the racial division and clear disparity between the European and non-European experiences.

Tom Rice (October 2008)

 

Works Cited

‘Marvels of the Universe’, Bioscope, 19 June 1919, 89-90.

Bioscope, 8 January 1920, 37.

‘Sound Words on Education’, Bioscope, 19 March 1921, 6.

Charleston Daily Mail, 4 April 1920, 12.

Charleston Daily Mail, 3 December 1920, 13.

 

Titles

  • PORT-OF-SPAIN, TRINIDAD (Archive)
Series Title:
GRANGER'S MARVELS OF THE UNIVERSE
 

Technical Data

Year:
1920
Running Time:
9 minutes
Film Gauge (Format):
35mm Film
Colour:
Black/White
Sound:
Silent
Footage:
797 ft
 

Production Credits

Production Countries:
Great Britain, USA
Director
BRUCE, Robert C.
Production Company
Educational Films Corporation of America
 

Countries

 

Themes

 

Genres